JacobTheRox, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Pope Leo XIV recently weighed in on the abortion debate in the United States, questioning those who proclaim themselves "pro-life" but support the death penalty or harsh policies against immigrants. His comment comes amid controversy over the Chicago Archdiocese's plans to honor Senator Dick Durbin.
Context of the recognition of Senator Durbin
The Archdiocese of Chicago had proposed granting a “Lifetime Achievement Award” to Democratic Senator Dick Durbin in recognition of her work defending immigrants. This measure sparked debate within the Catholic community, given her stance in favor of legal abortion.
The Pope's statements
When questioned by journalists in Castel Gandolfo, Pope Leo XIV did not refuse to comment on this political-theological tension. He said—in English—that:
- "Someone who says 'I'm against abortion' but supports the death penalty, is not really pro-life.”
- “Someone who says 'I'm against abortion,' but agrees with the inhumane treatment of immigrants in the U.S., I don't know if that's pro-life.”
- He recognized the complexity of ethical issues: that not everything is resolved or black/white, and that it is important to look at the body of work of a politician in addition to his particular positions.
What reactions has your speech had?
- His comments clearly criticized a biased "pro-life" view limited to abortion without extending to other dimensions of human life (the death penalty, the dignity of migrants).
- In particular, when it comes to political figures like Durbin, the Pope suggests that service history and immigration policies should also be taken into account when assessing whether someone lives up to Catholic doctrine on life.
- The debate touches on a raw nerve within the Catholic Church in the United States, where tensions exist between more conservative and more progressive sectors over how to apply social doctrine to electoral and moral politics.
With these statements, Pope Leo XIV sends a clear message: being "pro-life" cannot be limited to rejecting abortion; it must encompass a coherence that includes respect for life at all stages and in all its conditions. In the American political context, this reminder calls into question positions that seemed compatible within public debate, but which, in the pontifical judgment, could be contradictory from the perspective of Catholic teaching.
For more stories like this, follow More Latin.
Sources:
English 
Spanish 